Thread:Aks6609/@comment-5691012-20190701160230/@comment-24761405-20190701171440

I personally don't believe Kim could be considered to have murdered Frank, as although she left him to die, she didn't cause his weak heart and she didn't bring on the heart attack by spiking him, or poisoning him, ect. I can't comment on if Phelan did or didn't kill Michael as I only vaguely remember it, and even then, it's irrelevant.

Like Frank's death, Max, Katie and Sarah's deaths may or may not be considered murders depending on your perspective. It looks like Qazwsx mentioned in his edit summary for removing Max and Katie from Robert's page that because the definition of murder is premeditated act of killing, he doesn't believe Robert murdered them so he removed that.

All these deaths are open to interpretation which is why I strongly, strongly believe the Emmerdale wikia should follow Corriepedia in scrapping the Murderer/Murder Victim categories and also removing the kill counts as it would save a hell of a lot of disagreements.

Both you and Qazwsx have undo each others valid edits over the past few weeks. I believe both of you have good intentions with regards to your edits, which is nothing to apologise for. The problem lies in differences of opinion and lack of communication and discussion. I should've intervened earlier to prevent it getting so bad and for that I apologise. Hopefully this situation doesn't arise again, but if it does, maybe try leaving a message the other person's wall to discuss things before engaging in edit warring.

I believe both you and Qazwsx have good intentions but Qazwsx a bit of a bad habit of undoing edits which means a ban will be headed his way once whether Kim did or did not murder Frank is sorted out.

Aks