Libby rented stables at Butlers Farm for her and her sister Tamsin's horses. Both Max King and Andy Sugden were interested in having a relationship with Libby, but she had a boyfriend. After dumping her boyfriend, Libby began a relationship with Andy. Things were going well between the pair until June 2005 when Andy discovered his sixteen year old former girlfriend, Debbie Dingle, had given birth to his daughter Sarah. Andy dumped Libby and got back with Debbie to try to give his daughter a proper family. Libby left the village not long afterwards.